Dog training collars are helpful tools when handling difficult breeds or working dogs with important roles. However, there are some mixed views on the use of dog shock collars for the correction of pets. It all depends on the method and intensity of the of product. Those that produce a strong electrical current can be a little distressing for both dog and owner. Models with vibrations and sounds modes are preferable in many situations. Still, the device has to be reliable enough to aid with training.
Reliability comes from the means of administering correction, but also the durability of the device. This is where these waterproof, tough models help. Waterproofing is important when training dogs near water. If you are training them to behave off the leash with other animals, the device can’t pose a risk if the dog plays in puddles or ponds. Then there are those learning to fetch items as part of obedience training, or as working dogs. The following dog shock collar reviews look at models for large dogs and small dogs, with different pros and cons.
Dog Shock Collar Reviews
1. Ipets 100% Waterproof & Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
The statement of 100% waterproof is always a bold claim, and here it is seen with both the electric dog collar and the transmitter. This means that it is safe to drop the remote in water without any risk to the dog or yourself.
When it comes to the modes of correction with this model, we see some clear pros and cons.
PROS
CONS
There is a choice of static shocks, vibrations and noises. There is also the chance to adjust the level between 1 and 100. The plus side here is that there is great variation on a range of options to suit different users. The downside is the potential effect of a level 100 static shock on a small dog. There is a range of 900ft and clear buttons, although many say that it work better close range than long range. This would bring the device more in line with other electric dog collars that have a range around 400-500ft.
2. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
This model is more about the transmitter than the vibration dog collar. The mode of correction is pretty simplistic, with talk of a gentle tapping rather than the more intense shocks of other vibration dog collars. Like the Ipets model above, there is the chance to adjust this within 100 levels, only this time there is also a boost stimulus if needed.
PROS
CONS
The transmitter is a small, handheld device made to be discreet. This means that it is easy to operate one-handed, with basic controls, but also easy to hide from the dogs. If they see the remote, they may know what is coming. They need to associate the vibration with their behavior for the best results. This model has a rechargeable lithium polymer battery, different sized contact points for different breeds of dog and is waterproof. There are the usual complaints about malfunctions and obstructions to the signal, but nothing this isn’t seen with many other devices.
3. Petrainer 100% Waterproof and Rechargeable Dog Shock Collar
The specification of this remote shock collar is very similar to that of the first iPets model. As this PetTrainer version is currently listed as a bestseller, this shows that it is a formula that works. Again, there is that debate over the best mode of correction with the use of static. But there are enough choices here with the static modes, vibrations and noises over that same 1-100 intensity range.
PROS
CONS
A feature that does appear to be different here is the adjustability of the collar. Users can increase the size by 25 inches, which makes it more suitable for small dogs as well as larger ones. There is also a second collar in the box. As long as users synchronize the transmitter and receiver, they should have a good experience. However, there are some concerns about the battery life. Some say it struggles to hold its charge. This is where that second collar is helpful.
4. Garmin Delta XC Dog Training Collar Bundle
The name Garmin always brings high hopes for the quality and performance of a device with a long range transmitter. We trust Garmin to send our cars and bikes in the right direction, so we should be able to trust them to control an anti bark dog collar for small dogs from half a mile. This model is immediately appealing because of the small size of the collar and transmitter. It is easy to use the device without the dog seeing what you are about to do.
PROS
CONS
The collar is also adjustable for different dogs, with different correction settings on the stimulation, vibration and tone. Users are able to adjust it in circumference and it comes with two sets of contact points. Some people wont be too keen on the idea of 18 levels of continuous stimulation. But, the choice of correction options means this doesn’t have to be used. There is also a bit of a learning curve here due to the lack of instructions.
5. SportDOG Brand 425 Family Remote Trainers
The name family is interesting here is there is an added benefit to this no bark collar that other electric dog training collars don’t have. This model has the option of connecting three collars to one remote. This means that homes with many pets can add on collars and train animals simultaneously. This saves on some time and stress. The receiver is customizable to suit different needs, as is the collar itself.
PROS
CONS
It adjusts from 2 to 22 inches, so is ideal for small breeds. Some may also think of using this as a collar for cats to really go with that family idea. Thankfully there is also a decent instruction manual to help new users get the hang of it all.
This waterproof model really is waterproof, not just resistant to rain. It is submersible up to 25ft, so can go into ponds. It also has 7 levels of static over a 500 yard range. There are some inconsistencies, and reports of contact points coming off, but is generally reliable for stubborn pets.
6. Dogtra iQ Plus Remote Trainer
Many of the receivers on the vibration dog collars above have clear buttons with symbols for the pulse, noise and vibration. This means it is easy to understand the function straight away, which therefore cuts down the time it takes to start training. This Dogta model does things a little differently. Here there are 3 buttons for 3 options. They are N for nick, C for continuous and P for page. This doesn’t really makes as much sense until users test this out. They need to understand what page means first.
PROS
CONS
Once they get up and running, many people do like the warning of the page setting and find it to be effective. They also like the shape of the transmitter, but feel it is too easy to ramp up the intensity on the dial. Still, there are plenty of bonuses here with the 400yrd range, 2hr quick charge and the adjustable nature of the collar.
7. PatPet Dog Training Collar, Rechargeable & Waterproof
One of the interesting features with this PatPet remote shock collar is the idea of blind operation. Dog owners don’t want to take their eyes off their pet when correcting them, especially in potentially dangerous situations. Therefore it helps to have a transmitter you can use without looking down, or without thinking too much.
PROS
CONS
This remote offers that intuitive, simple use with separate buttons for each command, as well as an “anti-stuck” design for ease of operation. There is also the chance to switch the intensity of static from 1-16, or the vibration from 1-8.
The collar is nylon and adjustable for grater comfort for different sized dogs. Most would also agree that it is 100% waterproof and pretty responsive. There are still mixed comments about the effectiveness, but users have to figure out which setting is best for their dog and his behavior issues.
8. PetSafe Yard & Park Add-A-Dog Collar
PetSafe is another brand that companies are quick to turn to when they need a reliable piece of pet friendly equipment. Their products range from training devices to fences, and there is a sense that they understand how to help dogs and owners alike. One detail that owners should note here is that this is a barking collar best suited for large dogs.
PROS
CONS
This one goes to neck sizes up to 28 inches, whereas many others in this guide stop at 25. Those 3 inches could make a big difference. There are 8 levels of static and 2 different tones with this model, but no vibration. It is waterproof for outdoor play in all weathers, and has a 400yd range. There are not as many settings as some models, but enough for most users to find the right tone/setting for their needs. Another notable problem here is that there aren’t appropriate contact points for large breeds that are also quite hairy.
9. Veckle Dog Shock Collar
The first thing that is noticeable about this pair of collars in the Veckle Shock Collar bundle is the color. Many of these top models are black, perhaps so they are a little more discreet on the dog. Not all owners want to show off the fact that they are using this sort of device. Here they have gone from bright orange and yellow so it is immediately visible. Those collars are once again adjustable for small dogs to medium sized breeds. There are also soft contact points to reduce the risk of irritation. Again this could also be a cat shock collar.
PROS
CONS
The range isn’t that strong compared to some of the other models, at just 2600ft. But, there are plenty of correction modes to use via the small remote. There are 99 levels of vibration, shock or tone so users can choose the best approach. Like the other models here, both the transmitter and collar are waterproof and durable for added piece of mind. There are plenty of positive dog shock collar reviews for this model, although some note an issue with the eco-friendly sleep mode on the collar.
Best No Bark Collars
1. TBI Pro - Rechargeable Anti Bark Collar
The majority of these dog anti-bark collars for dogs tend to allow users to choose between three different types of correction. They can either use the static shock, vibration or a tone in order to get their dog to correct their behavior. This TBI Pro electric collar does things a little differently. There are three modes here – sound, sound and vibration or sound and shock. The downside here is that users have to use the tones no matter what, even if their dogs don’t respond well to the sound.
PROS
CONS
The other thing that makes this device different is the means of triggering the response. Users will also like the the rechargable battery which can last for 10 days before the next charge, as well as the waterproofing and adjustable fit.
2. SportDOG Brand NoBark Rechargeable Collars
The last model in these dog shock collar reviews is another that is purely designed to handle barking. Buyers will immediately note that this is quite a small, sleek device compared to some other models around. Like the option above, this rechargeable model has a series of settings with no risk of false corrections.
PROS
CONS
The problem is that there are complex modes of Temperament Learning, Progressive Correction, and User-Selected static correction. There is no tone or vibration. This wont suit those wary of static collars.
This device is also designed to be tough. It is well built with waterproof housing and the strength to deal with rough play. It is submersible up to 10ft and also has heavy-duty lithium ion battery that should last 200 hours. The collar is also adjustable between 5 and 22 inches for large dogs and smaller breeds.
Leave a Reply